Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Phil's avatar

Hi, I'm a fan of your work.

I still fondly think back to the times when I was reading wonderfully skeuomorphic books in "Classics", checking Twitter with "Tweetbot" and, yes, taking a glance at "Ultraviolet" before heading out. It was a time where browsing through the app store was delightful and you made a lot of those small delights happen. I admit, I never used Thermo much (Haze was a lot more useful to me), but I never regretted unlocking all the features I didn't use. I felt proud to have this piece of art on my phone. Thank you for making it.

Nowadays, I prefer physical books over phone apps, Mastodon over Twitter and whimsical little apps made by some people in Denmark are few and far between. And when you started this newsletter, it brought some of that delight back. People still care about thoughtful design! It brought me hope that if we cared enough, we can go back to a culture "where UI wasn’t just about efficiency but about expression". I really enjoyed reading your critique of Liquid Glass.

However, your recent evangelism of GenAI services put a stop to that enjoyment.

I don't want to waste my breath trying to tell you about how relying on those services even for tasks you don't enjoy is still affecting the quality of your work, about the exploitative nature of the services or about it's bad for your mental health and that the phrase "I talked to my assistant about this" signals a level of anthropomorphization that enables psychological harm; to say nothing about the extreme environmental damage caused by that industry.

I just want to say that as a software dev by trade, where I initially felt enthusiastic about the possibilities of "AI" and the power that comes with it, I now feel disappointed by how easy people throw any task they don't personally find appealing into an AI service and call it a day. Now we have 2000 mediocre apps with maybe some good parts in them instead of 2 good apps. The ability to "single dev" an app without having to collaborate with others who can do the parts you're not good at is causing people not to. And I fear that is doing a lot of damage to our communities. It isolates us.

I'm afraid, I can't follow you where you're going.

So long and thanks for all the fish!

3 more comments...

Ready for more?